- "We have our Frozen Yogurt Machine, and it has four different flavors: Triple Fudgy Chocolate, Vanilla Bean Dream, Sweet Peachy Peach, and Berry Berry Raspberry. All I am going to ask you to do is bring back some yogurt. However, I want a mix of just three of those flavors. So on the bottom I want (bottom flavor), then in the middle I want (middle flavor), and then on the top I want (top flavor). You bring back the yogurt exactly the way I want it, I will give you an extra $250!"
- ―David Ruprecht
There are four flavors of Frozen Yogurt offered in the market. The store's Honey Hill Farms Yogurt Shoppe frozen yogurt dispenser dispenses Triple Fudgy Chocolate, Vanilla Bean Dream, Sweet Peachy Peach, and Berry Berry Raspberry. David will ask the players to get a combination of three of those flavors, in a specific order. Three-cup yogurt cups are available with lines marking one cup increments. Players must dispense the yogurt into the cup one cup at a time, filling the cup up to the designated line. Placing the lid on the cup and the cup in the mini-basket attached to the players' cart before the bell rings rewards the team with an additional $250.